Compare Providers

Overview: Originally established to serve government employees, GEICO has grown to be one of the largest insurance providers in the U.S.
Strengths: Competitive rates, especially for safe drivers and multi-car households; strong online presence and mobile app capabilities.
Limitations: While they offer various types of insurance, their strength is primarily in auto insurance. Some customers prefer a more personalized touch with local agents, which GEICO lacks in some areas.

Overview: Progressive is known for its “Name Your Price” tool, which allows users to state their budget and find a suitable policy.
Strengths: The tool mentioned above, along with a vast array of discounts, especially for students, multiple vehicles, and homeowners.
Limitations: Their rates can be higher for drivers with a history of accidents or violation

Overview: State Farm is the largest auto insurance provider in the U.S., priding itself on its extensive network of agents.
Strengths: Personalized service with agents ready to assist in nearly every locale. Offers a wide variety of insurance and financial products.
Limitations: Premiums can be on the higher end, especially when not bundled with other State Farm products.

Overview: Beyond auto insurance, Allstate offers everything from home and renters insurance to business and commercial policies.
Strengths: Diverse policy offerings; Drivewise program rewards safe driving with discounts.
Limitations: Rates can be pricier than some competitors. Some customers report rate hikes after filing claims.

Overview: With over a century in the business, Farmers has built a reputation for stability and comprehensive coverage.
Strengths: Provides specialized policies, such as for rideshare drivers. Offers a wide array of discounts.
Limitations: Some users find their online tools less user-friendly than those of younger competitors.

Overview: Known for its customizable policies, Liberty Mutual provides options to match unique needs.
Strengths: “Only pay for what you need” philosophy can result in cost savings. Offers a vast range of coverage options.
Limitations: Despite customization, some customers report higher base rates.